OAK — OnChain Attack Knowledge

Worked example · 2026-11

Pennysia — Settlement V1 arbitrary external call spent users' leftover token approvals — Pennysia Settlement V1 / Ethereum — 2026-11-12

Loss
~$5K (5,006.133489 USDC, 0.05 wstETH and 101,000 YUNO, per Lookonchain and RektRadar; the amounts match the token transfers of the attack transaction traced by OAK). Total loss and victim count beyond this one transaction are undisclosed. No reimbursement statement was found.
OAK Techniques observed
OAK-T9.004 (Access-Control Misconfiguration — primary, per SlowMist. The Settlement contract let the caller choose the target and calldata of an external call, so the contract's own token allowances could be spent by anyone. This is the same missing-input-validation sub-pattern as Li.Fi 2024 and Transit Swap 2022. See techniques/T9.004-access-control-misconfiguration.md). OAK-T4.004 (Allowance / Approve-Pattern Drainer — downstream: the loss was limited to approvals users had granted and not revoked). OAK-T7.003 (Cross-Chain Bridge Laundering — a MetaBridge bridge call carried the wstETH onward; traced by OAK, destination undisclosed).
Attribution
unattributed (attacker address 0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300 per SlowMist; no further attribution published).
Key teaching point
A settlement or router contract that holds user token approvals must never let the caller pick the target and calldata of an external call; restrict targets to an allowlist that excludes token contracts, and let users approve exact amounts. Here users had approved the Settlement contract for swaps and left the allowances open, so one arbitrary call turned them into the attacker's balance.

Summary

On 2026-11-12 at 13:59:11 UTC an attacker contract 0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A was called from 0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300 in block 26399314 (0x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732d). The transaction made the Pennysia Settlement contract 0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E execute transferFrom on four holders' leftover approvals and forward the tokens to the attack contract, which sent them to the attacker EOA. SlowMist reported after user reports of stolen funds and told anyone who had approved tokens to the Settlement contract to revoke. The mechanism is SlowMist's description of an "arbitrary external call"; the exact function and calldata were not published and OAK did not decode them.

Timeline (UTC)

Stages: Flaw (Settlement V1 deployed and used) → Preparation (attacker funded) → Take (one transaction) → Money (USDC and wstETH moved within about a minute) → Response. Times are block timestamps traced by OAK.

When What happened OAK
Before 2026-10-26 (undisclosed) Settlement V1 0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E (verified as PennysiaSettlement, deployed by 0xDa70eC0779aB1904B7eb6C32f308B1a1C163fCB8) is live and users call executeSwap against it, e.g. from 2026-10-26, leaving approvals open. The exploitable external call existed from deployment or a later change; undisclosed. T9.004
2026-11-12 13:37:35 to 13:38:35 The attacker EOA receives three small ETH transfers from three different addresses (about 0.0029, 0.0043 and 0.0058 ETH) to pay gas. The senders are not identified. —
2026-11-12 13:59:11 0x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732d: the attacker calls the attack contract, which makes the Settlement contract spend approvals of four holders: 0xF2Ff84D45783BD64913903516FA44B419F266998 (5,000 USDC), 0x61081de92Ad52c786719537D84a4534A398bf76a (6.133489 USDC), 0x56EbC608fD6B8F8CeF2775a3Ee0DddaEc01A7000 (0.05 wstETH) and 0x40A86E910AB2E709cb552f6F8A979bc90D669497 (101,000 YUNO). Each token goes victim → Settlement → attack contract → attacker. T9.004, T4.004
2026-11-12 13:59:47 0x523f691f946ca7aa9f15999c2b828d2bde678241b303ca17a95df26365ea56e3: the attacker sends all 5,006.133489 USDC to 0xd492f207c2C2520Dcb13eD04AfA81aAae66C9378, an EOA. On 2026-11-13 22:08:35 that address sends the USDC to the contract 0x9A47f3289794E9bbc6a3C571f6D96Ad4E7bAED16 (0x945e60e35b130546d7d6805f88e6c3a049958342995b06f1bd1225825c276b74); onward path not traced. T7.003
2026-11-12 14:00:47 0xbb5ce35d3e307da88f74e32d28906f05d12ca2cf1faeef646f9c854f69e3323f: the attacker calls bridge on MetaBridge 0x0439e60F02a8900a951603950d8D4527f400C3f1 with 0.05 wstETH, which goes to the same contract 0x9A47f3289794E9bbc6a3C571f6D96Ad4E7bAED16; within that transaction the wstETH is split, swapped and passed on to other addresses. Final destination undisclosed. T7.003
2026-11-12 14:12 to 14:16 The attacker receives 0.003907565135158029 WETH and unwraps it to ETH (0x259e51ede919db3f4e40b57f4c614f77aa3ac545bc12634053c35045c199634a). —
2026-11-12 22:09 onward The attacker sends token transfers of 5,006.133489 units labelled "USDC" (with non-standard characters in the token symbol) to several addresses that begin with 0xd492 and end with 9378, the same pattern as the real holding address. Those are not the USDC contract; this looks like address-poisoning bait and is an OAK observation, not a sourced claim. —
2026-11-12 The 101,000 YUNO is not moved by the attacker in the transfers OAK checked. —
2026-11-12 to 2026-11-13 SlowMist issues a TI alert listing the Settlement contract and attacker and urges revocation; Lookonchain and RektRadar repeat it. RektRadar says no pause, patch or reimbursement announcement was found, and the contract was still live. No statement from Pennysia was located. response

Key addresses:

Fund flow

All transfers as a table (15)
Time (UTC)FromToAmountOAKTxBasis
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZVictim 1
0xF2Ff84D45783BD64913903516FA44B419F266998
Pennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
5,000 USDCT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZPennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
Attack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
5,000 USDCT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZAttack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
Attacker
0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300
5,000 USDCT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZVictim 2
0x61081de92Ad52c786719537D84a4534A398bf76a
Pennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
6.1335 USDCT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZPennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
Attack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
6.1335 USDCT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZAttack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
Attacker
0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300
6.1335 USDCT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZVictim 3
0x56EbC608fD6B8F8CeF2775a3Ee0DddaEc01A7000
Pennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
0.05 wstETHT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZPennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
Attack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
0.05 wstETHT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZAttack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
Attacker
0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300
0.05 wstETHT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZVictim 4
0x40A86E910AB2E709cb552f6F8A979bc90D669497
Pennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
101,000 YUNOT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZPennysia Settlement V1
0x3Aad97E5a91b8e43b7Dc830aCEb004307678795E
Attack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
101,000 YUNOT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:11ZAttack contract
0x96Bb89E3F86312968cE11A1bD8d9d28F4891a17A
Attacker
0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300
101,000 YUNOT9.0040x2716c50e450272240f68f2827bcb4a336c2ac520951e0e530154566c295b732dtraced by OAK
2026-11-12T13:59:47ZAttacker
0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300
USDC holding address
0xd492f207c2C2520Dcb13eD04AfA81aAae66C9378
5,006.1335 USDCT7.0030x523f691f946ca7aa9f15999c2b828d2bde678241b303ca17a95df26365ea56e3traced by OAK
2026-11-12T14:00:47ZAttacker
0x813A5aB666AdeBa907548235fbAc087642878300
Contract that received USDC and wstETH (unlabelled)
0x9A47f3289794E9bbc6a3C571f6D96Ad4E7bAED16
0.05 wstETHT7.0030xbb5ce35d3e307da88f74e32d28906f05d12ca2cf1faeef646f9c854f69e3323ftraced by OAK
2026-11-13T22:08:35ZUSDC holding address
0xd492f207c2C2520Dcb13eD04AfA81aAae66C9378
Contract that received USDC and wstETH (unlabelled)
0x9A47f3289794E9bbc6a3C571f6D96Ad4E7bAED16
5,006.1335 USDCT7.0030x945e60e35b130546d7d6805f88e6c3a049958342995b06f1bd1225825c276b74traced by OAK

Root-cause evidence

Public references

Techniques demonstrated (3)

More incidents